Latest News

• Add My News • Search Old News

Gippsland › Latest news › Howard S. Emanuel

A Matter of Attitude - Howard Emanuel

Recent comments by the Prime Minister regarding the lack of skilled tradespersons in Australia has struck a poignant chord with me. Read More...

By Howard Emanuel - 3rd October 2004 - Back to News

Recent comments by the Prime Minister regarding the lack of skilled tradespersons in Australia has struck a poignant chord with me. In this instance I agree with the PM that it is indeed as much about community attitudes than any other reason why we now as a nation face a critical shortage of fully trained tradespeople.

Perhaps it all began in the late 1980s when we essentially closed down many of the purpose focused "Technical Schools" and integrated them into secondary colleges. This move I think sent a message to the community about the value of taking up a trade apprenticeship upon leaving school, a community it seemed increasingly wanting to be seen as a "white collar" society.

Now fast forward to today and we have a situation in some Victorian universities where the first year drop out rate is as high as 22% and a mean average rate of 18% across the sector.  Perhaps too many of our young are going on to university due to peer pressure and in one sense responding to the social dogma of the day. That is that a university education will allow you to work in the white collar mandate and essentially give you a higher social standing than would be the case if you were to become a lowly tradesperson, a member of the so called working class. Pretty sad parody this, but essentially true.

It has become noticeably obvious that in the minds of many it is more desirable to be office bound than to wear overalls and work boots. Yet a great many of our young struggle with the demands of university and one has to ask the question whether their unique abilities are best suited to long term tertiary education, or are more likely to gain full expression in one of the trades.

And of course without the trades where would we be when we are in need of such expertise around the home, the workplace, even the office, perhaps we just don’t ask that question of ourselves.

One thing is certain as the PM has said it is community attitudes that are making it difficult for many to feel free to access training for a trade, to indeed follow their natural instincts, instead only to languish at university desperately trying to keep up with those beholden of gifts of another kind and in the meantime suffering all manner of negative perceptions and feelings about their own worth.

Come on Australia, where’s that egalitarian attitude we so often speak of, that penchant for a fair go. Nothing to my mind is so misguided and ignorant as class attitudes, those insidious notions that somehow one particular mandate in life makes us the better of those not similar. Fortunately history is full of examples that fundamentally debunk this myth, if only we care to admit it to ourselves; what.

Of course the overriding contradiction I can’t but help notice in the Prime Ministers argument is that it is indeed often the attitudes of the political and social elite that percolate such misunderstandings in the community, but that is for another day.

Thank you.

Howard Emanuel.

Independent Candidate for the Federal Seat of McMillan.

Convener: Rural Social Justice Movement

Tele/Fax: (03)5684 1561

Mobile: 0400 158 896

E-mail:   howard@howardemanuel.com

Website: www.HowardEmanuel.com

"Bringing the People back into Policy!"

Source: http://gippsland.com/

Published by: kris@howardemanuel.com

• Meet with South Gippsland Mayor Hersey to discuss ideas or issues that matter to you and your community and other council updates
  South Gippsland Shire Council is offering multiple opportunities for community engagement, upcoming events, free workshops, grants, vaccination sessions, and council services throughout Summer 2026 for residents and local businesses.
• Tim Bull criticises Minister Dimopoulos for dismissing G-Wagon concerns, warning Gippsland’s fire preparedness is reduced
  Tim Bull criticises Environment Minister Dimopoulos for dismissing concerns about withdrawn G-Wagon firefighting vehicles, warning Gippsland faces reduced fire preparedness and urging clear answers before the upcoming fire season.
• Latrobe City urges the Victorian Minister for Roads and Road Safety urgent activation of Traralgon Bank Street and Princes Highway traffic lights
  Latrobe City Council urges Victorian Ministers to urgently activate the Bank Street–Princes Highway traffic lights in Traralgon, addressing safety concerns after completed works remain non-operational since 2018.
• Melina Bath appointed Shadow Minister for Outdoor Recreation, championing regional lifestyles and economic opportunities
  Melina Bath has been appointed Shadow Minister for Outdoor Recreation, pledging to champion outdoor access, community wellbeing, and the vital economic and lifestyle benefits outdoor activities bring to regional Victoria.
• Melina Bath slams Agriculture Minister Ros Spence for ignoring Gippsland farmers' struggles under Labor's tax regime
  Melina Bath criticised Agriculture Minister Ros Spence for refusing to advocate for Gippsland farmers, citing VFF survey results showing overwhelming concern over new taxes and Labor's disregard for regional agriculture.
• East Gippsland Mayor Jodie Ashworth urges vigilance, community support and preparedness during recent extreme heat and bushfire risks
  East Gippsland Mayor acknowledges recent extreme heat, commends community responses, urges vigilance, bushfire preparedness, checking on vulnerable people, accessing support services, and using Vic Emergency app and Emergency Dashboard.
• Martin Cameron slams Energy Minister D'Ambrosio's false claims on power prices and jobs in Latrobe Valley
  Nationals MP Martin Cameron condemned Energy Minister Lily D'Ambrosio's claims of delivering for Latrobe Valley, citing soaring power prices, weak jobs growth, and neglect of residents during Victoria's energy transition.
• Martin Cameron urges Energy Minister to lift outdated coal overlays blocking 2000 new homes in Traralgon
  Nationals MP Martin Cameron criticised Minister Lily D'Ambrosio for refusing to review outdated coal overlays blocking 2000 new homes in Traralgon, despite studies confirming land stability for development.
• Darren Chester welcomes Minister Catherine King’s confirmation that the Eastern Beach Road intersection remains a priority
  The federal government has increased funding to $6.6 million for the Lakes Entrance road safety upgrade, but Federal MP Darren Chester says state government delays continue to stall the vital project.